Choosing a hospital with Medicare: quality, costs and discharge

An empty hospital room with two beds and bedside equipment

Most people never choose a hospital. They go to the one closest to home, or the one where their doctor practices, and that is often the right call. But the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) points out something worth knowing before you need it: research shows that some hospitals do a better job than others at caring for patients with certain conditions. When you have time to plan, such as a scheduled surgery or a condition you know will need hospital care later, the hospital you pick can matter.

This guide walks through CMS's four steps for choosing a hospital, how to compare hospital quality with Medicare's own tools, who inspects hospitals, what Medicare covers and what you pay in 2026, long-term care hospitals, your rights while you are in the hospital, and how to plan for the day you go home. It is based on the CMS booklet Guide to Choosing a Hospital (November 2025), the CMS Discharge Planning Checklist (December 2025) and Medicare.gov's hospital coverage pages.

First, the rule that overrides everything else

CMS is blunt about this: when you have a life-threatening emergency, always go to the closest hospital. Everything in this guide is for the times you can plan, not for a heart attack, a stroke or a serious injury. Comparing quality scores is for a hip replacement scheduled next month, not for chest pain tonight.

If you are in a Medicare Advantage Plan, note how CMS frames the network question further down: it is about care that is not emergency care.

Step 1: Talk to your doctor

The booklet starts with your doctor, because your doctor often decides where you can go. CMS suggests asking yourself these questions:

  • Do you have a specific doctor or surgeon in mind?
  • Does that doctor or surgeon participate in Medicare, and in your Medicare Advantage or other Medicare health plan if you have one?
  • Which hospitals is your doctor or surgeon affiliated with, or does your doctor have privileges at?

CMS adds a detail many people do not expect: while your primary care doctor may admit you to the hospital, a different doctor may provide your care once you are there. If continuity with a particular doctor matters to you, ask who will actually be treating you.

Getting a second opinion before surgery

When it is not an emergency and your doctor says you have a health problem that needs surgery, you have the right to a second opinion. A second opinion is another doctor's view of your health problem and how it should be treated.

Here is how Medicare handles it:

  • Part B helps pay for a second opinion on medically necessary, non-emergency surgery. After the Part B deductible, you pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount for the visit.
  • Tests the second doctor orders are covered the same way Medicare covers other medically necessary services.
  • If the first and second opinions disagree, Medicare covers a third opinion, again at 20% of the Medicare-approved amount after the deductible.

The same second-opinion rules apply in a Medicare Advantage Plan, with a catch. CMS notes that some plans will help pay for a second opinion only if you have a referral from your primary care doctor, or only from a doctor in the plan's network. Call your plan before you book the appointment.

Step 2: Think about your personal and financial needs

The second step is about fit. CMS lists these questions:

  • Are there alternatives to hospital care for what you need?
  • Does the hospital participate in Medicare?
  • Does the hospital meet your practical needs, like location and visiting hours?
  • Will you need care after you leave the hospital? If so, what kind, who will arrange it, and do you have to meet certain requirements to get it?

The participation question is not a formality. Medicare.gov lists two conditions for Part A to cover inpatient hospital care: you are admitted as an inpatient with a doctor's order saying you need inpatient care to treat your illness or injury, and the hospital accepts Medicare.

The question about care after you leave matters just as much. If you may need a skilled nursing facility afterward, Medicare generally requires a 3-day inpatient hospital stay immediately before the nursing facility admission. Time spent as an outpatient, including observation, does not count. Our skilled nursing facility guide explains that rule in detail.

Extra questions if you have Medicare Advantage

If you are in a Medicare Advantage Plan or another Medicare health plan, CMS adds two questions:

  • Do you need permission from your plan, like a preauthorization or a referral, before you are admitted?
  • For care that is not an emergency, do you have to use hospitals and providers, like surgeons and specialists, that are in your plan's network?

These questions can narrow your choices more than any quality score. A hospital with excellent ratings does you little good if your plan will not pay for a planned stay there. Medicare.gov also notes that Medicare Advantage Plans may charge copayments during the first 60 days of a hospital stay, when Original Medicare charges nothing beyond the deductible. Your plan's documents spell out what you will pay. Our Original Medicare vs. Medicare Advantage guide compares the two.

Step 3: Compare hospitals on experience and quality

This is where CMS suggests you dig in. The booklet's questions:

  • Does the hospital have experience treating patients with your condition, or doing the procedure you need?
  • How does the hospital perform compared with all hospitals across the country?
  • Does it do well on quality measures, like infection rates and complications?
  • How do patients rate their experience there? For example, were they satisfied with how doctors and nurses communicated, how quickly staff responded, and how clean the hospital was?
  • Do you need a specific type of hospital, such as one that offers medical, surgical or psychiatric care?

What good hospital quality means

CMS defines good quality hospital care as getting the care and treatments known to give the best possible results for your condition. Good care supports your recovery and lowers your chance of problems. CMS is clear that not all hospitals give the same quality of care.

Most hospitals run programs to check and improve their own care, either by reviewing information from patient charts or by surveying patients about their stay. Many report what they collect to their state and to Medicare. Medicare, the states and others in the hospital industry use that information to push hospitals to improve.

Using Medicare's Care Compare tool

The tool CMS points you to is Care Compare at Medicare.gov/care-compare. Click the "Hospitals" link, enter your location and select "Search" to see hospitals near you. The results include Veterans Administration medical centers and military hospitals, which matters for many retirees with VA or military coverage.

You can compare up to 3 hospitals side by side: select "Compare" next to each hospital's name, then select "Compare" in the blue banner at the top of the page. You can compare hospitals near you or anywhere in the country. According to CMS, you can compare them on four kinds of information:

  • What patients thought of their stay. Recently discharged patients get a survey about how well doctors and nurses communicated, how clean and quiet the hospital was, and how well they were prepared for discharge.
  • Timely and effective care. How often hospitals give the recommended treatments for certain conditions, like heart attacks and sepsis.
  • Whether patients got better. How a hospital's rates of readmission, complications and death for certain conditions compare with national rates.
  • Whether the hospital orders too many tests. How each hospital uses outpatient medical imaging, like CT scans, to assess patients.

You do not have to sort through this alone. Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) gives free help comparing hospitals; find yours at shiphelp.org. You can also call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227). TTY users can call 1-877-486-2048.

Prices are public, too

Quality is only half of the comparison. Medicare.gov notes that hospitals are now required to share the standard charges for all of their items and services, including the charges negotiated by Medicare Advantage Plans, on a public website. That information can help when you weigh a planned procedure, especially if you have a Medicare Advantage Plan or are paying part of the bill yourself.

Who inspects hospitals

To take part in Medicare, a hospital must follow Medicare's health and safety regulations. Two kinds of organizations can check whether it does:

  • Your State Survey Agency, a state agency that inspects health care facilities in Medicare and Medicaid and investigates complaints.
  • A national accreditation organization whose hospital program Medicare has approved.

Each hospital chooses which route it uses, and CMS says you can ask any hospital you are considering how it is evaluated.

Medicare has approved the hospital accreditation programs of 4 national organizations. If a hospital you are considering is accredited by one of them, you can contact that organization to find out what information it can share about the hospital's performance. You can also contact it with a complaint about an accredited hospital. The contact details below are as printed in CMS's November 2025 booklet.

Accrediting organizationContact (as listed by CMS)
The Joint Commission1-630-792-5800
jointcommission.org
American Osteopathic Association1-800-621-1773 or 1-312-202-8000
osteopathic.org
DNV GL Healthcare1-866-523-6842
dnvaccreditation.com
Center for Improvement in Healthcare Quality (CIHQ)1-866-324-5080
cihq.org

You can also ask your State Survey Agency for copies of its survey reports or other quality information it has on a hospital. State Survey Agencies handle complaints about accredited hospitals as well. CMS keeps a list of State Survey Agency contacts on CMS.gov, and 1-800-MEDICARE can help you find yours.

Step 4: Make the choice

CMS's last step is short:

  • Talk with someone you trust about the hospitals you are comparing.
  • Ask your doctor or health care provider how the information you gathered applies to you.
  • Choose the hospital that is best for you.

The middle point is the one CMS singles out: the numbers on Care Compare are general, and your doctor can help you see how they apply to your own condition.

What Medicare covers in the hospital

If you have both Part A (Hospital Insurance) and Part B (Medical Insurance), you can get the full range of Medicare-covered services in a hospital. How Medicare pays depends on whether you are an inpatient or an outpatient.

As an inpatient (Part A)

Medicare.gov lists these covered inpatient hospital services:

  • Semi-private rooms
  • Meals
  • General nursing
  • Certain drugs, including methadone to treat an opioid use disorder
  • Other hospital services and supplies you get as part of your inpatient treatment

Inpatient hospital care includes care in acute care hospitals, critical access hospitals, inpatient rehabilitation facilities, inpatient psychiatric facilities and long-term care hospitals, plus inpatient care you get as part of a qualifying clinical research study. If you also have Part B, it generally covers 80% of the Medicare-approved amount for doctors' services you get while you are in the hospital.

Medicare does not cover:

  • Private-duty nursing
  • A private room, unless it is medically necessary
  • A television or phone in your room, if there is a separate charge for it
  • Personal care items, like razors or slipper socks

What you pay as an inpatient in 2026

Original Medicare measures hospital use in benefit periods. A benefit period begins the day you are admitted as an inpatient and ends when you have gone 60 days in a row without inpatient hospital care (or skilled care in a skilled nursing facility). If you go back into the hospital after a benefit period ends, a new one begins, and you pay the deductible again. There is no limit on the number of benefit periods.

Days in the benefit periodWhat you pay in 2026
Days 1–60The $1,736 Part A deductible, then $0 a day
Days 61–90$434 a day
Days 91–150$868 a day while you use your 60 lifetime reserve days
After day 150All costs

Lifetime reserve days are 60 extra days Medicare will pay for when you are in the hospital more than 90 days. You can use each one only once in your lifetime. One more limit: Part A pays for up to 190 days of inpatient mental health care in a freestanding psychiatric hospital over your lifetime. That cap does not apply to a Medicare-certified psychiatric unit inside an acute care or critical access hospital.

See our Part A costs page for the full 2026 figures, including the Part A premium.

As an outpatient (Part B)

You can spend the night in a hospital and still be an outpatient. You are an outpatient when you get emergency department services, observation services, outpatient surgery, lab tests, X-rays or other hospital services and the doctor has not written an order admitting you as an inpatient. If you are in the hospital more than a few hours, CMS says to always ask your doctor or the hospital staff whether you are an inpatient or an outpatient. If you get observation services for more than 24 hours, the hospital must give you a written notice called the Medicare Outpatient Observation Notice (MOON).

As an outpatient, Part B covers the hospital services, and the costs work differently:

  • Doctors' services: you usually pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount after the Part B deductible ($283 in 2026).
  • Hospital copayment: you also usually pay the hospital a copayment for each service you get in its outpatient department, except certain preventive services. In most cases, that copayment cannot be more than the Part A deductible for each service.
  • Critical access hospitals: at these small rural hospitals, your outpatient copayment may be higher and may exceed the Part A deductible.
  • Your daily pills: Part B generally does not cover prescription and over-the-counter drugs you take yourself in an outpatient setting. Many hospitals do not let you bring drugs from home, for safety reasons. If you have a Part D drug plan, it may cover these drugs, but you will likely pay up front and file a claim with your plan for a refund.

Medicare.gov also notes that you may pay more for outpatient services in a hospital outpatient setting than for the same care in a doctor's office that is independent of the hospital. When you have a choice of where to get a planned test or procedure, ask about the cost in each setting.

A critical access hospital, by Medicare's definition, is a small rural facility more than 35 miles from another hospital (or 15 miles in mountainous terrain or areas with only secondary roads). It provides emergency care around the clock, has 25 or fewer inpatient beds, and keeps an average stay of 96 hours or less for acute care patients.

Long-term care hospitals

"Long-term care" usually means help with daily activities like eating and dressing, the custodial care people get in assisted living. CMS is clear that Medicare does not cover long-term custodial care. A long-term care hospital is something different, and Medicare does cover medical care there.

Long-term care hospitals are acute care hospitals for patients who need inpatient hospital care for a stay that lasts, on average, more than 25 days. Many patients transfer from an intensive or critical care unit and have more than one serious condition, but may improve with time and care and return home. Services may include:

  • Respiratory therapy
  • Head trauma treatment
  • Comprehensive rehabilitation
  • Pain management

Part A covers a long-term care hospital stay with the same 2026 day-by-day costs as a regular hospital: the $1,736 deductible, then $0 for days 1–60, $434 a day for days 61–90, $868 a day for lifetime reserve days 91–150, and all costs after day 150.

You may not owe the deductible a second time. Medicare.gov explains that if you already paid the deductible for a hospital stay in the same benefit period, that earlier stay counts toward it, because the benefit period began on its first day. Medicare.gov gives two examples where you would not pay another deductible:

  • You are transferred to a long-term care hospital directly from an acute care hospital.
  • You are admitted to a long-term care hospital within 60 days of being discharged from a hospital.

After leaving a long-term care hospital, many people go on to a skilled nursing facility or to custodial care in a long-term care facility.

Your rights while you are in the hospital

You have rights and protections in the hospital no matter where you get your care. You have the right to be included in decisions about your care, and the right to appeal certain decisions about your coverage. Our Medicare appeals guide covers the full appeal process.

If you think you are being discharged too soon

If you feel the hospital is asking you to leave too soon, you have the right to ask for a fast review of that decision by a Beneficiary and Family Centered Care Quality Improvement Organization (BFCC-QIO). This is an independent reviewer of doctors and other health care experts under contract with Medicare.

  • The hospital should give you a notice called "An Important Message from Medicare about Your Rights." It explains the fast appeal process and lists the BFCC-QIO's contact information.
  • If you do not get a copy, ask your nurse or the hospital's patient advocate, like an ombudsman, to give you one.
  • The BFCC-QIO reviews the decision and decides whether your covered services should continue.

The same idea applies after the hospital. If you are in a skilled nursing facility or a comprehensive rehabilitation facility, or getting home health or hospice services, the staff should give you a notice called a "Notice of Medicare Non-Coverage" before your covered services end. It also explains your fast appeal rights. CMS's advice for both notices is the same: read it carefully, and if you do not get one, ask for it.

Where to take a complaint

ComplaintWho handles it
The quality of care you, a family member or someone you care for got at a hospitalThe BFCC-QIO for your state
Other complaints about a hospitalYour State Survey Agency
A hospital accredited by one of the 4 organizations aboveThat accrediting organization, or your State Survey Agency

CMS says the BFCC-QIO is run for Medicare by one of two companies, Commence (formerly Livanta) or Acentra, depending on your state. Check their websites to make sure you contact the right one for your state, or call 1-800-MEDICARE for your BFCC-QIO's phone number.

Planning for the day you go home

Discharge planning starts long before discharge day. CMS says your doctor and the hospital staff will work with you during your stay to plan for it, and that you and your caregiver are important members of that planning team. CMS publishes a Discharge Planning Checklist for patients and caregivers leaving a hospital, nursing home or other care setting. It suggests using the checklist throughout your stay, discussing it with the staff (a discharge planner, social worker, ombudsman or nurse), and skipping anything that does not apply to you.

Questions to settle before you leave

  • Write down the names and phone numbers of people to call if you have questions or concerns.
  • Ask what complications to watch for and what to do about them.
  • Make a full list of your prescription drugs, over-the-counter drugs, vitamins and herbal supplements, including what you took at home and any changes made during your stay.
  • Review that list with the staff. Ask which items and doses to keep taking after you leave, and share the updated list with your health care providers.
  • Ask where you will get care after discharge and what your options are, like home health care. Tell the staff what you prefer.
  • Ask whether you will need medical equipment, like a walker, whether Medicare covers it, and who will arrange delivery.
  • Ask whether you are ready for daily activities: bathing, dressing, using the bathroom and climbing stairs; cooking, food shopping, cleaning and paying bills; driving to appointments and picking up prescriptions. Discuss the ones you need help with.
  • Ask the staff to show you and your caregiver how to do any task that needs a special skill, like changing a bandage or giving a shot, then practice it yourself.
  • Talk to a social worker if you are worried about how you and your family are coping with your illness.
  • Talk to a social worker or your health plan about what your insurance covers, what you will have to pay, and possible ways to get help with costs.
  • Ask for written discharge instructions you can read and understand, and a summary of your current health status. Bring them and your drug list to your follow-up appointments.

For the caregiver

CMS's checklist has a separate section for the family member or friend helping you:

  • Write down questions about the checklist or the discharge instructions and discuss them with the staff.
  • Make sure you can give the help the person needs. What tasks will you need help with? Do you need education or training? Raise it with the staff before discharge, and write down the name and phone number of someone you can call with questions.
  • Get prescriptions filled and run other errands, like buying food for a special diet, before the person is discharged, so you will not need extra trips.

If you need a nursing home or home health agency next

The same Care Compare tool covers far more than hospitals. CMS's checklist points to Medicare.gov/care-compare to compare the quality of home health agencies, nursing homes, dialysis facilities, inpatient rehabilitation facilities and hospitals in your area. Our guides to choosing a nursing home and Medicare home health care cover those decisions.

Other help CMS lists

  • SHIP: free counseling on health insurance, plus help with claims, billing and appeals. Visit shiphelp.org.
  • Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program: advocates for the rights of residents in long-term care facilities (LTCombudsman.org).
  • Senior Medicare Patrol: helps people protect themselves from Medicare and Medicaid fraud, errors and abuse (SMPresource.org or 1-877-808-2468).
  • National Council on Aging: information on programs that help pay for drugs, utility bills, meals and health care (BenefitsCheckup.org).
  • Medicaid: helps cover medical costs for some people with limited income and resources.

If you have limited income and resources, CMS notes you may also qualify for programs that help pay your health and drug costs. See our pages on Medicare Savings Programs and Extra Help.

A one-page summary

WhenWhat to do
EmergencyGo to the closest hospital. Compare later.
Planned surgeryAsk where your surgeon has privileges; consider a second opinion (Part B, 20% after the deductible).
Medicare AdvantageCheck network rules and whether you need a referral or preauthorization.
ComparingUse Care Compare (up to 3 hospitals at once); call your SHIP for free help.
During the stayAsk every day whether you are an inpatient or an outpatient.
Before dischargeWork through the discharge checklist; ask for the "Important Message from Medicare" if you think it is too soon.

CMS's booklet reminds readers that it describes Medicare at the time it was printed and that changes may occur. Check Medicare.gov or call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) for the latest. TTY users can call 1-877-486-2048.

Check our work

Every figure on this page was read from these official documents. Follow the links and compare.

To cite this page: Retiree Toolkit. "Choosing a hospital with Medicare: quality, costs and discharge." Updated November 14, 2026. https://www.retireetoolkit.com/guides/choosing-a-hospital-medicare